Step by Step Guide to Reviewing a Manuscript - Wiley

Consider the merits of the text in comparison to other related text. When evaluating the text you could answer some of the following questions: Is the question the text tries to answer relevant, interesting, new, or useful? To who, and why? Does the text give new answers or interpretations to an old question? Retrieved 8 June Archived from the original on Retrieved Rethlefsen, M.

Hassan Murad, Edward H. Livingston September 10, The Regents of the University of California. Academic publishing.

Reading a review article can save you time and give you a more well-rounded and coherent understanding of your topic. Unlike typical research articles, review articles do not present any original primary business case studies harvard business school. For this reason, some assignments may not allow you to directly cite a review article in your paper. However, you can still use the article to get a general understanding of the field and to find important primary research articles.

Also note that for most senior theses in the sciences, the proper place to cite a review article is in the first few paragraphs of your introduction. By placing references to a review article in your early intro, you give your reader a place to go for more information if they are unfamiliar with your field. Finding a review article is relatively simple, though it varies slightly depending on what database you are using. Start with a search in Web of Science.

Click article review format sample checkbox next to "Review" and then click "Refine" to see only the results classified as review articles. After your initial search in PubMedlook for the "Articles Types" filter on the left side of the page.

Be sure to uncheck other article types if you would like to limit your search to review articles. It is a critical, constructive evaluation of literature in a particular field through summary, classification, analysis, and comparison.

If you write a scientific review, you have to use database article review format sample to portray the research. The analysis, evaluation, and comparison require use theories, ideas, and research, relevant to the subject area of the article.

Much like all other reviews, a journal article review evaluates strengths and weaknesses of a publication. Article review sample essays differs from a journal article review by the way that it evaluates the research method used and holds that information in retrospect to analysis and critique. Scientific article review involves anything in the realm of science. Often, scientific publications include more information on the background that you can use to analyze the publication more comprehensively.

The format of the article should always adhere to the citation style required by your professor. When you know the answers to these questions, you may start writing your assignment. Articles appear most commonly in academic journals, newspapers, and websites.

If you write an article review in the APA formatyou will need to write bibliographical entries for the sources you use:. Web : Author [last name], A. A [first and middle initial]. Year, Month Date of Publication. Journal : Author [last name], A. Publication Year. Publication Title. Periodical Title, Sample article review Issuepp. Newspaper : Author [last name], A. Magazine Title, pp. Web : Last, First Middle Initial. Date Month Year Accessed.

Newspaper : Last, First M.This article begins with a discussion of Friesen's time in Kenya and some of the interactions he witnessed between the Massai people and the Canadian students who were there in a student exchange program for discipleship training.

Intrigued by this phenomenon, Friesen decided to do his doctoral work about proving, statistically, the long-term impact of short-term missions. The rest of the article discusses his research methodology and summarizes his main research results. Among his findings, I found the most fascinating to be the one that among short-term missions participants, there tends to be a decline in their church relationship after their experience and female participants tend to experience greater spiritual growth.

Based on my experiences with short term work and witness trips, I have found both of these to be true.

Sample article review

Friesen also found that pre-field discipleship leads to a higher score of overall change. I definitely agree with him concerning this matter, and I applaud many of the outlets for sending Nazarene short-termers in providing an opportunity to do this article review sample essays one leaves on a cross-cultural ministerial experience. Throughout the article, the author discusses other findings and then concludes with ways that churches and missions organizations can be helpful in facilitating positive growth-promoting work and witness experiences.

Don't: cover specific examples, statistics, or background information familiar to experts in the field. Do: capture the main points of each section, as space allows. Write your critique. Use your outline of opinions to write several paragraphs explaining how well the author addressed the topic.

Express your opinion about whether the article was a clear, thorough, and useful explanation of the subject. This is the core of your article review. Evaluate the article's contribution to the field and the importance to the field.

Decide if the author's points help her argument. Identify any biases. Decide if you agree with the writer, then provide sufficient support as to why or why not. Article review sample essays by suggesting which audiences would benefit from reading the article. Don't: fill your review with a long list of unrelated critiques.

Do: tie your grievances and praise together into a coherent argument, forming your own thesis. Conclude the article review. In a paragraph, summarize the main points of the article, as well as your opinions about its significance, accuracy, and clarity. If relevant, also comment on implications for further research or discussion in the field. The arguments in the article show the presence of bias, prejudice, argumentative writing without supporting details, and misinformation. Reread the review.

Look for grammar, mechanics, and usage mistakes. Make sure to cut any extra, unneeded information. Make sure you have identified and discussed the key issues in the article.

Alexander Peterman, MA.

How to Write a Psychology Critique Paper

Typically, you won't want to include tables or figures in your review, because this would usually indicate added information from your perspective.

However, you can reference tables and figures in the original work, such as by saying, "In Figure 2. Not Helpful 10 Helpful It would depend on the subject of the review article. If the article you're writing requires a lot of knowledge about outside articles, then you will need to read as many as possible, though there is no required minimum.

Not Helpful 3 Helpful The article title should be a succinct, ideally clever description of the general content. In this case, if you were writing a movie review for, say, a bad movie about a ship, you could say something like, "New Release Sinks at the Box Office.

Not Helpful 7 Helpful However, it's important that the articles you are going to use are connected to your study. Not Helpful 15 Helpful I would start by reviewing the poem's structure and how effective it is. This would include looking at some of the tools that the poem uses -- alliteration, rhyming scheme, metaphor, etc. I would also look at the message of the poem itself and see if it came across clearly and meaningfully.

Not Helpful 5 Helpful Not Helpful 8 Helpful Do I use references for each and every sentence when writing an article review? No, you don't have to write references in each and every sentence. Your review should mostly be composed of your own summary and arguments. Not Helpful 4 Helpful There are two ways. You write it not for the general public but for the readership familiar with the field of knowledge. This review is to summarize the essence of the article, its key arguments, and findings, article review sample the author's attitude towards the subject-matter.

You also assess the new knowledge that the author has brought to the discipline and its application potential. Writing an article review is not just about expressing your article review sample essays on the work.

It is a fully-fledged evaluation of the author's ideas expressed in the article. As you analyze the article, you use your own ideas and research experience. Your overall conclusions about the article base off on your own judgment backed up by your experience in this field and your common sense. You only talk about the research already performed by the article's author. You do not perform any new research yourself. You should article review sample essays exactly how you will be writing your article review before you even read the article in question.

Article review sample essays

This is because you should know which points of the article are most important to your review in advance. The article review outline usually goes like this:. Read the introduction, the conclusion, the first sentences of each paragraph.

Then read several opening paragraphs. Only then you should read the whole article. This first reading is only for getting the overall idea of the point that the author sought to make with this article. Carefully read the article several more times. If you are reading it from a screen, use article review sample essays highlighter for the most meaningful parts. If you are using a print version, use a pen. The most meaningful parts here are the main points and the facts to support them.

Instead, make notes on the margins and article review format sample connections between different parts of the article. Sometimes, there may be three or four main points, not just one. What are the author's general conclusions? Your critique: A critique is not whether you liked the article or not. Rather, you should assess whether the the main point s is really significant?

Does the author's argument support the main point s? Is the evidence convincing? Are there wider ramifications to the conclusions? Can you apply this information to subjects with which you are familiar? Name and describe at least two threats to the internal validity of the study design. Name and describe at least two threats to external validity of the study design.

How to write a literature review

In what way s is the sample representative of the target population? Present the strengths and weaknesses that you have found in the publication. Besides, highlight the knowledge that the author has contributed to the field. Also, write about the gaps and contradictions in the article. Take a standpoint of either supporting or not with the author's assertions but back your arguments with facts and relevant theories that are pertinent to the area of knowledge.

Rubrics and templates can also be used to evaluate and grade the person reviewing the article. In this section, revisit the critical points of your piece, your findings of the article, and your critique.

Also write about the accuracy, validity, and relevance of the results of the article review. Give way forward for future research in the field of study. Before submitting your article, keep these pointers in mind:. As you read your articles, highlight the key points. This will help you pinpoint the article's main argument sample article review the evidence that they use to article review sample that argument. While you write your review, use evidence from your sources to make a point.

This is best done using direct quotations. Select quotes and supporting evidence adequately and use direct quotations sparingly. Take a lot of time to analyze your articles.